Showing posts with label creative discipline. Show all posts
Showing posts with label creative discipline. Show all posts

Another Must-Read Parenting Book

A couple of months ago I put a fair bit of research into my awesome list of favorite discipline/parenting books, and in the course of putting it together came up with a few more books to check out.  A couple weren't so great, but one has totally changed the way I relate to my middle child.


Seriously.  Initially, I picked this book up because I just didn't believe that I could "Have a New Kid by Friday."  I was so wrong.

With our oldest (daughter), Love and Logic worked so perfectly that I couldn't see a need for anything else and just assumed that every kid would respond well to the reasoning and such that this method recommends.  Our son quickly showed us that we were way off base.  He would become so mad/frustrated/embarrassed that he didn't seem to be listening to our "reasoning" and we would drone on about this and that before "disciplining" him.  The fit would continue, power struggle would ensue, and our mediocre parenting would immediately bite us in the butt.  Big fail.  By the time he was three he was pretty much in control (although we still presumed ourselves to be).  Double fail. 

Have a New Kid by Friday puts in to practice some very Love and Logic-like principles (like natural consequences), but adds a few simple rules (which is EXACTLY what I need--rules to follow!) such as my new favorite:

Say it once, turn your back, and walk away.

One of the problems we were having was that we just didn't think that he got what we were saying so we would explain it thirty ways from Sunday, allowing the struggle to continue and the fit to escalate.  By following this rule you take the wind out of his sails and regain control. 

There are a few more simple guidelines in the first few chapters of the book (each of which has been highly effective and left me feeling so much calmer and more in control as a parent), but the real meat is the second two-thirds.  Dr Leman covers every conceivable topic, from bedwetting (don't make it a big deal, be mildly sympathetic, clean up and move on) and grocery shopping (don't offer treats as a reward for good behavior...of which I'm hugely guilty) to temper tantrums (yup, say it once, turn your back, and walk away) and whining (remove the offender to a place where he/she can whine without bothering you) with simple, easy to implement guidelines. 

Since we started, Scout has become infinitely more polite (most requests now begin with 'excuse me' and include 'please' and 'when you're done'...I never thought that we could get that far in such a short amount of time), kinder to his sisters ('I'm sorry, are you okay?') and has nearly quit making his ugly 'I'm mad at you' face at me.  Thank goodness. 

What's your favorite parenting rule of thumb?  Now that I've mastered "say it once, turn your back, and walk away" I'm ready to add to my repertoire :)
Another Must-Read Parenting Book SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Creative Discipline 103: The Button Jar

So, after reading all those great books and setting out some good rules with varying levels of success, nothing seemed to work with the very different personalities of my two oldest children (now 6 and 3 1/2) until we stumbled upon the button jar. This is the crux of discipline in our house.


The idea is simple. Fill a jar with many of something (I liked the buttons since I could buy a big bag of pretty, colorful ones at Hobby Lobby for a few bucks, but marbles, coins, popsicle sticks, anything small will work) and provide an empty cup or jar for each child. Set out the rules, then put a button in their cup whey you think they deserve it and remove one when they don't live up to your expectations (or, in the case of our 3 1/2 year old son, defy them outright). When a specific quantity of buttons is reached, a reward is earned. (The reward could be something simple like a trip for ice cream or to the zoo, or a large toy, depending on the motivation that your kid needs and what his/her interests are; the boy is expecting a pirate ship, our daughter would like ice skating).

Clearly, the assignment of buttons is somewhat arbitrary, but we go through periods where one child is being too rough with the baby so they are warned that when they are rough with her they are choosing to lose a button (see? they're in control, reducing the parent-child power struggle and making them accountable for their actions), but when they play nicely and follow the rules for quiet time they get a button. I'll also give out buttons when someone goes out of their way to help a sibling clean up a mess they didn't make, or asks to help empty the dishwasher (these things happen a lot more often since the button jar came along), etc. Failing to follow a rule (e.g. screaming for me from one end of the house or getting up before 6:30) loses a button. I can see this working until at least 12-13 years, although I'm expecting that the payout will be a bit bigger by then!

What do you do to keep your children in line?
Creative Discipline 103: The Button Jar SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Creative Discipline 102: House Rules

Once I filled my head with all these great disciplinary ideas, I realized that I had to set out a concise set of rules for the kids to follow. I sat down a wrote out a (very long) list of things that I thought were particularly important. Here's a small portion of that list: (image via bolsa bonita)

  • No jumping/climbing on the furniture.
  • No spitting.
  • No calling names.
  • No touching/playing with someone's else's special things.
  • No screaming.
  • Crying is okay.
  • No ruining what someone else is working on.
  • Be quiet during the baby's nap.
  • Don't leave a mess.
  • No laying on the floor and throwing a fit.
  • Listen to and mind what mommy and daddy tell you to do.
  • Put your dishes in the sink after you eat.
  • Put the toilet lid down so the baby doesn't splash around in the potty.
  • No going outside without asking.
  • No whining.
Clearly, no kid was going to remember all these rules, let alone follow them. I also didn't like that they all felt very negative. I try to speak to the children with a lot of "I statements" (I need you to stop yelling, I need you to get your feet off the couch, etc), and this was a lot of "NO!" which I already knew that they don't respond well to.

I managed to narrow all of this down to four rules that encompass all of the important ideas:
  1. No throwing a fit. If you throw a fit, go to your room until you feel better.
  2. Respect our things and each other.
  3. Use pleasant inside voices to speak nicely.
  4. Be a listener.
Much of whats important falls under rule #2 (no spitting, no touching someone's special things, no name calling) or rule #3 (no screaming, be quiet during naptime, no whining), and #1 and #4 round out good behavior. Further, they are extremely easy rules for me to follow. I could do beter at listening, and I do occasionally throw a bit of a fit (and I loooove to go to my room until I feel better). We keep the rules posted in the kitchen (with pictures for our non-readers), and refer to them when a consequence is imposed ("We are respectful with one another. Sitting on your sister's head is not respectful.")

I couldn't live without my rule #4. What's the most important rule in your house? Any that I need to add to my list?
Creative Discipline 102: House Rules SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Creative Discipline 101: Booklist

As a Developmental Psychologist I felt like discipline should come very easily to me (even if I'm not especially disciplined myself), but the reality of motherhood was actually very different. Even after I felt like I had really honed my skills on the first child, it turned out that she was a cupcake compared to her brother, who is happy to openly defy every rule and throw it in your face the minute he gets an opportunity (and relying on his impish, dimpled smile to get him out of trouble). Over time, though, I've figured a few things out--owing more to my creativity than any skill as a Developmental Psychologist--and I'll be sharing these ideas over the next few weeks.


First, the books. I'm a big reader and researcher. When I have a question I order a pile of books, skim through them, take notes, and really dig into the good ones. I had some ideas going into parenthood that I really didn't want to sacrifice. Namely, I did not want to discipline my children physically (e.g. spanking or slapping), I felt that it was important that they understand the 'why' behind rules, and I wanted to think of discipline less as a punishment-based strategy where I bossed the kids around and more as teaching the children to be disciplined in their actions. Lofty ideals, I know, and I've lost sight of them a few times, but all-told, I think I've found a good equilibrium, and these books really helped me get on track.

Love and Logic Magic for Early Childhood: Practical Parenting from Birth to Six Years: Admittedly, this is not a very pretty book, but it's an absolute goldmine of good parenting ideas. The basic concept of Love and Logic is to give children a good deal of control by giving them reasonable choices, and letting them fail sometimes (and accept the natural consequences). For example: cold weather strikes, child won't wear a jacket. That's their choice (jacket or no jacket. you decide.), and it won't hurt them to get a bit chilly. Take the coat along, they'll come to understand that they're cold and put the jacket on (or not, and they'll still be cold, but it's their choice, and will likely put the jacket on next time). If I could only have one book in my personal library this would be it.

New First Three Years of Life: Completely Revised and Updated: This would be the second book in my library and is full of utterly practical, realistic advice on raising children. His other book, Raising a Happy, Unspoiled Child, is also excellent and perhaps more straightforward. It goes age by age to get you started on the right foot and to help you teach your child to be happy and self-entertained rather than constantly demanding your attentions. Although it doesn't offer a whole lot in the way of disciplinary tactics from a remedial standpoint, it really falls under the category of teaching children to be disciplined.

Siblings Without Rivalry: How to Help Your Children Live Together So You Can Live Too: I got this book and read it cover to cover before our second was born. I patted myself on the back thinking that I would never have these sorts of troubles, and that I'd just keep the book on the shelf. Wrong, obviously. It's easy to read with lots of helpful anecdotes and cute little comic strips, and provides incredibly practical, effective advice to apply right away. Basic things that you'll feel like you should've been able to figure out like not breaking up your kids' arguments for them and not comparing them.

Healthy Sleep Habits, Happy Child: While this isn't a discipline book per se, it's become very clear to me that a grouchy, overtired kid is bound to be the wild terror in the family (speaking from experience). This book provides clear advice from birth on up to help your child get an adequate amount of sleep, including dealing with night terrors and scary dreams, special needs, and new siblings.

Other great choices:

Screamfree Parenting: The Revolutionary Approach to Raising Your Kids by Keeping Your Cool

Positive Discipline

1-2-3 Magic: Effective Discipline for Children 2-12 (123 Magic)

Parenting With Love And Logic (Updated and Expanded Edition)


Next up: 102: Rules @ the Kiddio House

What parenting books/ideas do you love? I'd love to hear your tips!
Creative Discipline 101: Booklist SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend